Carp, Kill them or let them go

[weaver 271]

CARP POLL Simple poll for curiosities sake, Kill them or let them go. No big explanations, No attacking any ones opinion and no big drawn out ones either. Quite simply hit the button you agree with most, I am doing a bit of research here and want to use the information gathered in a write up.Please do not turn this into a debate,

[samboman 319]

KILLSambo

[macmanluke 16]

ReleaseMainly due to difficulty in killing and disposing of them.

[fishnuts 55]

Kill, they make good Snapper burley .Cheers Dazz

[Guest Red Bull]

I went the "KILL" vote.I only fish for them when I need them for crab nets,or making up berley,otherwise,I leave them alone.

[ausea 4]

Don't think it's a good topic as it shows the law breakers for the one's for release

[macmanluke 16]

I think its more targeted at "release if it were allowed"

[Just Me 0]

Don't think it's a good topic as it shows the law breakers for the one's for release

Maybe "they" are just in favour of release as an opinion on the subject.Back to our regularly scheduled programme.

[weaver 271]

No big debates guys, this is running over a couple of sites and i will tally the info in 7 days time, The results will be in wild coast 26.

[SAFTAG 0]

Definitely kill them. They make GR8 fertilizer.

[brenton 637]

in any river KILL.....but

[doodlebug73 51]

if only i had more room in my freezer for crab and snapper berley/bait

[CARL 19]

KILL Good for Crab Bait Craybait and Snapper Berley

[spinyeel 2]

I think that if you vote yes,then you should have no problem with destroying all Spotted Vermin. AKA Trout. I'll sit on the fence here.

[Cleaver 65]

I think that if you vote yes' date='then you should have no problem with destroying all Spotted Vermin. AKA Trout. I'll sit on the fence here.[/quote']No problem at all. YES or NO answers, save your preaching for the 10 billion other carp threads.

[kadava 0]

I've voted. Interesting tally so far.

[spinyeel 2]

I think that if you vote yes' date='then you should have no problem with destroying all Spotted Vermin. AKA Trout. I'll sit on the fence here.[/quote']No problem at all. YES or NO answers' date=' save your preaching for the 10 billion other carp threads.[/quote']I've told you a gazillion times,not to exaggerate! Cleaver not so clever!

[Just Me 0]

Just praying a certain fresh water fisho doesn't see this thread...Carry on Cabbie.

[billygoat-ruff 25]

Kill them! Kill them all!

[Ugly4Life 41]

Kill is my vote. At least with Redfin they're supposedly pretty good to eat.

[Jack. 10]

Release has my vote... :ohmy:

[yorke_angler 0]

supposedly pretty good to eat.

being european, i have to disagree.. carp are a fantastic eating fish (if done right)!having said that though, you won't see me eating anything caught in the torrens :sick:

[yorke_angler 0]

Release has my vote... :ohmy:

into my bait freezer lol

[Just Me 0]

Oooooohhhh it's too close to call Forum member trolling :ohmy:

[yorke_angler 0]

crossbow fishing anyone? na a .22 will suffice

[pikk0n 2]

poor creatures... release them! feed them to the pelicans! don't kill... lol...

[fished out 0]

Kill the Mongrels!

[Yakmando 49]

Haha, classic JM. MIGHT GET YELLED AT!

[whyallabrad 0]

I voted release too...they're here FOR GOOD!NOT GOOD but NOT LEAVINGI'm with spiny too......Vermin are vermin kill all carp, trout, redfin, etc........Never gonna be the way so our natives have to adapt!....or perish...... Not just cod n callop, but galaxids, pygmy perch, river blackfish, etc..Hence my release vote.....nobody that fishes seriously could be a criminal for accidentally having a carp slip back when they release trout if they choose...trout even have a minimum size....??????Yes, yes, i know trout are a sportfish.........yes, yes and i have caught and killed and caught and released them too.....Maybe I'm a crook...But I see this as a poll of the current situation and as such kill or release...carp are here now!Cheers,lads n ladettes

[whyallabrad 0]

And trout only continue year in and year out for us because of a few hard working people involved with SAFFA and for all of us that appreciate trout fishing we should be thankful....but still it is not a clear cut issue.....fishos and greenies....both have a case here Not that i'm a greenie by any stretch .....*drawing up phlegm*andpitooey.....ting...yeah hit the spittle tray!!!!!!!

[stinger 0]

Release because its hard to kill them and dispose of them but if yous know how to kill them qiuckly and pianlessly then iw'll listen.

[fridge 6]

i love swatting flies,pretty painless i reckon

[afishyfish 4]

Kill all the ones you can and have fun doing it at teh same time

[Grazz64 0]

Kill them all as humanely as possible. Anyone who thinks different, well i cant print it tbh.

[Piranha 76]

Release because its hard to kill them and dispose of them but if yous know how to kill them qiuckly and pianlessly then iw'll listen.

simply sharpen a screwdriver on a grinding wheel then stick it into the carps brain, quick and simple, or use a strong knife